Top 10 Social Media Marketing Agencies in New York (2026)

New York City is the heartbeat of global trends, and in 2026, social media moves faster here than anywhere else in the world. For a business in the Big Apple, "posting regularly" is no longer enough to stay relevant. You are competing with viral creators, AI-generated content, and every other brand fighting for a second of a customer's attention. To win in NYC today, you need a partner who understands how to turn a simple scroll into a loyal customer. This guide highlights the top agencies in New York that are currently leading the charge in social media growth.

I’m Riten, founder of Fueler, a skills-first portfolio platform that connects talented individuals with companies through assignments, portfolios, and projects, not just resumes/CVs. Think Dribbble/Behance for work samples + AngelList for hiring infrastructure.

1. NinjaPromo

NinjaPromo has established itself as a powerhouse in the NYC marketing scene by blending high-level strategy with aggressive execution. They are known for their subscription-based marketing model, which allows brands to scale their creative output up or down depending on their monthly needs. Their team excels at taking complex industries, like fintech and crypto, and making them approachable through viral-style social content that resonates with modern audiences.

• Strategic Subscription Model: Their unique pricing structure allows businesses to access a full team of designers, strategists, and managers for a set monthly fee, providing the flexibility to pivot strategies without renegotiating contracts every time a new trend emerges.
• Full-Stack Creative Production: They do not just post; they build. From high-end video production to interactive AR filters for Instagram, their creative studio is designed to produce thumb-stopping content that stands out in a crowded 2026 social feed.
• Aggressive Growth Mapping: Every campaign starts with a deep dive into the Growth Map, a document that outlines exactly how social engagement will lead to revenue, ensuring that your marketing spend is never just a vanity expense.
• Multi-Channel Synchronicity: They ensure that your brand voice remains perfectly consistent across TikTok, LinkedIn, and even emerging decentralized social platforms, preventing the fragmented brand issue that many growing companies face today.
• Real-Time Data Dashboards: Clients receive access to live reporting tools that track every metric that matters, allowing for mid-campaign adjustments based on what the audience is actually clicking on in real-time.

Why it matters: In a city like New York where every second counts, NinjaPromo’s ability to act as an all-in-one extension of your team means you spend less time managing vendors and more time seeing your brand trend globally.

2. Socialfly

Socialfly is a female-founded agency that has become the go-to for B2C and lifestyle brands looking to build deep emotional connections with their audience. They specialize in the Social-First Approach, which means they design campaigns specifically for the way people consume content on their phones rather than trying to adapt TV or print ads for a small screen.

• Authentic Influencer Partnerships: They have a proprietary database of micro and nano-influencers in NYC and beyond, focusing on creators who have high trust scores rather than just high follower counts to ensure your brand message feels like a genuine recommendation.
• Vertical Video Mastery: With the total dominance of short-form video in 2026, Socialfly’s in-house studio focuses almost exclusively on TikToks and Reels that feel native to the platform rather than looking like a traditional, polished commercial.
• Community Management & Listening: They provide 24/7 community monitoring, which means they are interacting with your customers in the comments and DMs, turning casual observers into loyal brand advocates through real-time human conversation.
• Social Commerce Integration: They are experts at setting up and managing Social Shops, helping your brand sell products directly within social apps so that the journey from seeing a post to buying a product is seamless and instant.
• Audience Sentiment Analysis: Beyond just likes and shares, they use advanced AI tools to track how people feel about your brand, allowing them to shift messaging before a small PR hiccup turns into a major crisis.

Why it matters: For NYC brands in the fashion, beauty, or lifestyle space, Socialfly provides the human touch that is often lost in data-heavy marketing, ensuring your brand feels like a friend to your followers.

3. VaynerMedia

Founded by Gary Vaynerchuk, VaynerMedia remains a titan in the New York advertising world by prioritizing attention over everything else. They are famous for their high-volume content strategy, producing hundreds of pieces of micro-content to see what sticks before putting significant ad spend behind it. This reverse-engineered approach to marketing makes them incredibly efficient for large-scale brands.

• Culture-First Content Strategy: They employ a team of creators who live and breathe internet culture, ensuring that your brand is never late to a trend and always participates in a way that feels authentic and non-corporate.
• Rapid Iteration Testing: Their process involves launching dozens of creative variations simultaneously to gather data on what specific demographics respond to, allowing them to optimize campaigns with surgical precision.
• Direct-to-Consumer Expertise: They have a deep understanding of how social media drives sales, making them an ideal partner for eCommerce brands that need to move products quickly while building long-term brand equity.
• Platform-Native Storytelling: VaynerMedia rejects the idea of "matching luggage" campaigns, instead creating unique assets for every platform to respect the specific psychology of users on LinkedIn versus TikTok.
• Integrated Media Buying: Their social media management is tied directly to their media buying team, ensuring that the people making the ads and the people buying the space are in constant communication to maximize ROI.

Why it matters: If you have the budget to play at the highest level, VaynerMedia’s "volume leads to quality" philosophy is the most proven way to capture and hold the attention of the modern consumer.

4. Taktical Digital

Taktical Digital is a performance-driven agency located in the heart of New York that treats social media as a rigorous science. They are known for their "Growth Hacking" roots, focusing on technical optimizations and A/B testing to ensure every dollar spent on social ads returns multiple dollars in revenue. They are particularly strong in the B2B and high-growth startup sectors.

• Precision Audience Targeting: They use advanced data modeling to find hidden audience segments that your competitors are ignoring, allowing you to acquire customers at a significantly lower cost than the industry average.
• Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO): They do not just care about the click; they analyze the entire user journey from the social post to the final checkout page, suggesting improvements to your website to ensure social traffic actually converts.
• Scalable Paid Social: Their specialty is taking a small, successful campaign and scaling it to six or seven figures in monthly spend without losing the efficiency of the original return on ad spend.
• Dynamic Creative Optimization: They utilize AI-driven tools to automatically swap out headlines and images based on what an individual user is most likely to click, creating a personalized experience for every single viewer.
• Whitelabeled Creator Ads: They excel at running "dark posts" or whitelabeled ads through creator accounts, which often see much higher engagement rates than ads coming directly from a brand's main profile.

Why it matters: For businesses that need to justify every cent of their marketing budget, Taktical Digital provides the analytical rigor and technical expertise to turn social media into a predictable revenue engine.

5. Movement Strategy

Movement Strategy is an independent social media agency that focuses on building digital communities for some of the world's most recognizable brands. They believe that social media should be a two-way street, focusing on creating experiences that encourage fans to participate in the brand's story rather than just consuming it.

• Community-Led Growth: They specialize in building and moderating Discord servers, Facebook groups, and niche community hubs where your most loyal fans can interact with each other and your brand directly.
• Experiential Social Campaigns: They often bridge the gap between the physical and digital worlds, creating NYC-based pop-up events that are designed specifically to be shared and talked about on social media.
• Always-On Engagement: Their team ensures that your brand is "always on," responding to mentions and joining relevant conversations across the web to keep your brand at the top of mind for your target audience.
• Strategic Brand Voice Development: They spend significant time crafting a unique "persona" for your brand, ensuring that every caption and comment feels like it is coming from a real person with a distinct personality.
• Emerging Platform Research: They have a dedicated lab that tests new social platforms and technologies as they emerge, allowing their clients to be the first to establish a presence on the "next big thing."

Why it matters: Movement Strategy is perfect for brands that want to move beyond "followers" and start building a loyal "tribe" that will defend and promote the brand organically.

6. The Sasha Group

A subsidiary of VaynerX, The Sasha Group was created specifically to bring big-agency thinking to small and mid-sized businesses. They focus on education and consulting alongside execution, helping NYC entrepreneurs understand the "why" behind their social media strategy while providing the tools to execute it effectively.

• Entrepreneurial Coaching: They offer workshops and consulting sessions for founders, helping them build their personal brands and understand how to lead their own in-house marketing teams as they grow.
• Lean Content Production: They specialize in "scrappy" content creation that looks professional but doesn't require a Hollywood-sized budget, making them ideal for growing companies that need high-quality assets.
• Full-Funnel Social Strategy: They map out the entire customer journey, ensuring that social media is supporting everything from top-of-funnel awareness to bottom-of-funnel customer retention and loyalty.
• Agile Media Management: Their media buying team is trained to be highly responsive, shifting budgets between platforms daily based on where they see the best performance for your specific business goals.
• Brand Identity Refinement: They help companies sharpen their messaging and visual identity before launching social campaigns, ensuring that the foundation of the brand is strong enough to support rapid growth.

Why it matters: If you are a growing NYC business that needs high-level strategy without the massive overhead of a global firm, The Sasha Group provides the perfect balance of expertise and accessibility.

7. Iron Roots

Iron Roots is a specialized agency that focuses on "UGC" (User-Generated Content) and short-form video ads. They have built a massive network of creators in New York who can produce high-converting, authentic content on demand. They are the agency you hire when you need your ads to not look like ads.

• Custom Creator Sourcing: They do not just use "influencers"; they find real people who fit your exact customer profile to create testimonial-style content that feels incredibly trustworthy to viewers.
• Performance-First Editing: Their editors are trained in "Hook-Point" psychology, ensuring that the first three seconds of every video are designed to grab attention and prevent the user from scrolling past.
• Rapid Content Turnaround: Because they work with a decentralized network of creators, they can produce and ship dozens of new video assets every week, allowing for constant testing and refreshing of ad creative.
• Platform-Specific Optimization: They understand the subtle differences between what works on TikTok, Reels, and YouTube Shorts, tailoring every piece of content to fit the specific algorithm of the platform it is hosted on.
• Data-Driven Creative Briefs: They use historical performance data to write the scripts and briefs for their creators, taking the guesswork out of content creation and ensuring every video has a high probability of success.

Why it matters: In an era where consumers are increasingly blind to traditional advertising, Iron Roots’ focus on authentic, creator-led content is the most effective way to build trust and drive sales.

8. Lilo Social

Lilo Social is a boutique agency based in Brooklyn that specializes in scaling eCommerce brands through a mix of creative storytelling and performance marketing. They take a holistic view of the "Customer Lifecycle," using social media to not only acquire new customers but also to increase the lifetime value of existing ones.

• Retention-Focused Social: They design campaigns specifically for your existing customers, using social media to keep them engaged with the brand and encourage repeat purchases through exclusive "insider" content.
• High-End Visual Storytelling: Their creative team excels at producing aesthetic, high-production-value content that makes your products look like luxury items, even if they are at an accessible price point.
• Integrated Paid and Organic: They believe that paid and organic social should work in perfect harmony, using organic posts to build community and paid ads to drive the final conversion.
• Transparent Multi-Touch Attribution: They use advanced tracking to show you exactly how many touchpoints a customer had with your social media before they finally made a purchase, giving you a clear picture of your ROI.
• Proactive Account Management: Clients work directly with senior strategists who are deeply involved in the day-to-day execution of the account, ensuring that the strategy is always aligned with the brand's goals.

Why it matters: Lilo Social is the ideal partner for Brooklyn-born eCommerce brands that want to scale globally while maintaining their unique, creative identity and high-end brand feel.

9. Crafted NYC

Crafted is a "Brand-First" creative agency that focuses on the intersection of design, technology, and social media. They are experts at creating "Digital Experiences" that go beyond a simple post, often building interactive websites or mobile apps that are promoted through highly curated social media campaigns.

• Luxury Brand Positioning: They have a deep expertise in the luxury and high-end lifestyle sectors, knowing exactly how to use social media to build "prestige" and "desire" for premium products and services.
• Design-Centric Social Feeds: They treat a brand’s Instagram or Pinterest feed as a curated art gallery, ensuring that every single post contributes to a cohesive and visually stunning brand aesthetic.
• Interactive Social Assets: They specialize in creating interactive content like quizzes, polls, and AR filters that encourage users to engage with the brand for longer periods than a standard image or video.
• Sophisticated Brand Messaging: They avoid the "cringey" or over-the-top trends that many agencies chase, instead focusing on high-level copywriting that speaks to the intelligence and taste of a more sophisticated audience.
• Full Digital Ecosystem Integration: They ensure that your social media strategy is perfectly aligned with your website design, email marketing, and overall digital presence to create a seamless brand experience.

Why it matters: If your brand relies on a high-end, polished image, Crafted NYC provides the design expertise and strategic restraint necessary to succeed on social media without cheapening your brand.

10. Flightpath

Flightpath is a long-standing New York agency that has successfully navigated every major shift in the digital landscape. They offer a comprehensive suite of social media services, from strategy and content creation to community management and paid media, all backed by decades of experience working with global enterprises and local nonprofits alike.

• Strategic Business Alignment: They start every engagement by understanding your core business objectives, ensuring that social media is a tool used to solve real business problems rather than just a place to post.
• Comprehensive Social Audits: They provide deep-dive audits of your current social presence and your competitors, identifying "gaps" and opportunities that you can capitalize on to gain an advantage.
• Multi-Generational Marketing: They understand how to speak to different age groups across various platforms, making them an excellent partner for brands that have a broad customer base ranging from Gen Z to Baby Boomers.
• Robust Crisis Management: With their years of experience, they are experts at handling social media PR crises, providing a steady hand and strategic guidance to protect your brand's reputation during difficult times.
• Educational Client Partnerships: They view themselves as an extension of your team, providing regular training and updates on the latest social media trends to help your internal staff stay informed and empowered.

Why it matters: Flightpath provides the stability, experience, and broad expertise of a traditional New York agency with the agility and technical knowledge of a modern digital shop.

Final Thoughts 

Success in the New York social media scene now requires a blend of high-speed "culture-jacking" and deep, data-driven strategy. The agencies that made our list have proven they can balance these two worlds, helping brands maintain a human touch while scaling their reach globally. As we move further into 2026, the focus has shifted heavily toward vertical video, social commerce, and authentic community management. When choosing your partner, ensure they are not just "managing" your accounts, but actively growing your brand’s equity and revenue through creative innovation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the average cost of social media marketing in New York in 2026? While prices vary significantly based on the scope of work, most reputable New York agencies charge monthly retainers ranging from $3,000 to $15,000. Small businesses might find starter packages around $1,500, while enterprise-level strategies that include daily content production, influencer management, and heavy ad spend can easily exceed $25,000 per month. The cost usually reflects the level of seniority in the team and the complexity of the industry.

How long does it take to see real results from a social media agency? You should expect to see "early wins" such as increased engagement and brand awareness within the first 30 to 60 days. However, for significant growth in sales, lead generation, or community size, a timeline of 4 to 6 months is more realistic. Social media is a long-term play that relies on building trust with an audience, though paid social campaigns can often drive immediate traffic within the first few weeks of launching.

Should I hire a specialized social media agency or a full-service marketing firm? If your primary goal is to dominate platforms like TikTok or Instagram with high-end creative, a specialized social media agency is often better because they live and breathe those platforms. However, if you need your social media to be perfectly integrated with your SEO, email marketing, and website design, a full-service firm might be more efficient to avoid "fragmented" messaging across different vendors.

What are the most important KPIs to track with an NYC agency in 2026? Move beyond "vanity metrics" like likes or follower counts. In 2026, you should focus on engagement rate (shares and saves), click-through rates to your website, and actual conversion value. For B2B brands, tracking "share of voice" on LinkedIn is crucial, while B2C brands should look closely at social commerce revenue and customer acquisition cost (CAC) through social channels.

How do NYC social media agencies stay ahead of algorithm changes? Top agencies in New York often have direct relationships with platform representatives at Meta, TikTok, and LinkedIn, giving them early access to new features and algorithm insights. They also utilize advanced AI-driven listening tools that monitor performance trends across thousands of accounts in real-time, allowing them to pivot your strategy the moment a platform's reach begins to shift.

What is Fueler Portfolio?

Fueler is a career portfolio platform that helps companies find the best talent for their organization based on their proof of work. You can create your portfolio on Fueler. Thousands of freelancers around the world use Fueler to create their professional-looking portfolios and become financially independent. Discover inspiration for your portfolio

Sign up for free on Fueler or get in touch to learn more.