Top 10 Performance Marketing Agencies in New York (2026)

Are you tired of your marketing budget disappearing into the digital abyss with little to show for it? In the bustling metropolis of New York City, where competition is fierce and consumer attention is a precious commodity, finding a performance marketing agency that truly delivers can be a game-changer. By 2026, the landscape of digital advertising will have evolved dramatically, demanding more than just ad placements. You need a strategic partner who can navigate the complexities of AI-powered analytics, personalize user experiences, and drive measurable results that directly impact your bottom line. This guide will help you identify the top agencies poised to elevate your brand's performance in the coming year.

I’m Riten, founder of Fueler, a skills-first portfolio platform that connects talented individuals with companies through assignments, portfolios, and projects, not just resumes/CVs. Think Dribbble/Behance for work samples + AngelList for hiring infrastructure.

1. R/GA

R/GA stands out as a global innovation leader that seamlessly integrates technology, design, and marketing to create transformative brand experiences. They are not just about running campaigns; they focus on building sustainable growth engines for their clients. Their approach involves deep dives into consumer behavior and market trends, allowing them to craft highly effective, data-driven strategies that resonate with target audiences and drive significant conversions. Their work often spans across various digital touchpoints, ensuring a cohesive and impactful brand presence.

• Integrated Digital Strategy: R/GA develops comprehensive digital strategies that combine media planning, content creation, and user experience design to deliver a unified and powerful message across all platforms. This ensures that every touchpoint works together to guide the customer journey effectively.
• Data-Driven Performance Optimization: They leverage advanced analytics and machine learning to continuously monitor campaign performance, identify key insights, and make real-time adjustments. This iterative process ensures that campaigns are always optimized for maximum ROI, adapting to changing market conditions and consumer behaviors.
• Brand and Experience Innovation: Beyond traditional marketing, R/GA specializes in creating innovative brand experiences and digital products that enhance customer engagement and loyalty. They explore new technologies and platforms to give their clients a competitive edge in how they connect with their audience.
• Global Reach and Local Expertise: With offices worldwide, including a significant presence in New York, R/GA combines global perspectives with a nuanced understanding of local markets. This allows them to execute campaigns that are both globally consistent and locally relevant, catering to diverse audiences effectively.
• Consultative Partnership Approach: R/GA works as a true partner with its clients, offering strategic consulting that goes beyond campaign execution. They aim to understand a client's business goals deeply and provide long-term solutions that drive sustained growth and market leadership.

Why it matters: R/GA's holistic approach ensures that your performance marketing efforts are not isolated but are deeply integrated into your overall business strategy. This means not only achieving short-term gains but also building a strong, resilient brand that can adapt and thrive in the ever-changing digital landscape of New York.

2. Media.Monks

Media.Monks is a global digital-first marketing and advertising services company that specializes in building and executing scalable content, data, and digital media solutions. They are known for their ability to deliver complex projects at speed and scale, leveraging a vast network of specialists across various disciplines. Their strength lies in combining creative excellence with robust technological capabilities, making them a powerhouse for brands looking to dominate the digital space with highly efficient and impactful performance campaigns.

• Integrated Content and Media Solutions: Media.Monks offers end-to-end services, from creative concept development and content production to media planning and buying across all digital channels. This seamless integration ensures consistency in messaging and maximum efficiency in campaign execution.
• Advanced Data & Analytics Capabilities: They utilize sophisticated data platforms and analytics tools to uncover deep audience insights, optimize campaign targeting, and measure performance with precision. Their data-driven approach allows for highly personalized and effective advertising strategies.
• Scalable Global Production Model: With a unique global production model, Media.Monks can deliver high-quality digital assets and campaigns at an unprecedented scale and speed. This agility is crucial for brands needing to rapidly adapt to market changes and launch campaigns across multiple regions.
• Expertise in Emerging Technologies: Media.Monks is at the forefront of leveraging emerging technologies such as AR, VR, and AI to create immersive and interactive performance marketing experiences. This forward-thinking approach helps brands engage audiences in novel and memorable ways, boosting campaign effectiveness.
• Full-Service Digital Ecosystem: They provide a comprehensive suite of digital services, including digital media, search engine optimization (SEO), social media management, and programmatic advertising. This integrated ecosystem ensures that all digital marketing efforts are harmonized and optimized for collective success.

Why it matters: For businesses operating in New York, Media.Monks provides the agility and scale needed to compete effectively in a crowded market. Their ability to integrate creative content with data-driven media execution means your campaigns will not only reach the right audience but also resonate deeply, driving superior performance.

3. WPP (Through its various agencies like GroupM)

WPP is one of the world's largest advertising and marketing services companies, housing numerous specialist agencies under its umbrella, such as GroupM for media investment management. While WPP itself is a holding company, its individual agencies in New York are titans in performance marketing, offering unparalleled expertise in media planning, buying, and optimization. They leverage vast resources, proprietary data, and advanced technologies to deliver highly sophisticated and impactful campaigns for some of the world's biggest brands.

• Unrivaled Media Buying Power: Through GroupM, WPP agencies command significant media buying power, allowing them to secure premium placements and negotiate favorable rates across all digital and traditional channels. This scale translates directly into more efficient ad spend and broader reach for clients.
• Advanced Audience Targeting and Segmentation: They utilize sophisticated data analytics and audience intelligence platforms to precisely identify and segment target audiences. This enables the creation of highly personalized and relevant ad experiences that significantly improve engagement and conversion rates.
• Comprehensive Performance Measurement & Attribution: WPP agencies employ advanced measurement frameworks and attribution models to accurately track campaign performance and understand the true impact of each marketing touchpoint. This ensures transparency and continuous optimization based on tangible results.
• Global Network of Specialists: Clients benefit from a vast global network of experts in various fields, including search engine marketing (SEM), social media advertising, programmatic media, and e-commerce marketing. This access to specialized talent ensures that every aspect of a performance campaign is handled by industry leaders.
• Proprietary Technology and Tools: WPP invests heavily in developing proprietary technologies and tools for data management, media optimization, and campaign automation. These advanced platforms provide a competitive edge in planning, executing, and analyzing performance marketing initiatives.

Why it matters: Partnering with a WPP agency in New York gives you access to an unparalleled combination of resources, data, and expertise. Their sheer scale and sophisticated approach ensure that your performance marketing campaigns are executed with maximum efficiency and impact, delivering strong ROI in a highly competitive market.

4. VaynerMedia

Founded by digital visionary Gary Vaynerchuk, VaynerMedia has rapidly become a leading full-service global agency known for its aggressive, data-driven, and culturally relevant approach to marketing. They specialize in helping brands build their presence across all digital platforms, with a strong emphasis on social media, content creation, and always-on engagement. Their performance marketing strategies are deeply integrated with their creative output, ensuring that campaigns are not only effective but also highly shareable and resonant with modern audiences.

• Social-First Content Strategy: VaynerMedia excels at creating compelling, platform-specific content designed to thrive on social media channels. Their approach prioritizes organic reach and engagement, which then fuels paid amplification for maximum performance and virality.
• Rapid Iteration and A/B Testing: They employ an agile methodology for campaign development and optimization, constantly testing different creatives, audiences, and ad formats. This rapid iteration allows them to quickly identify winning strategies and scale successful campaigns efficiently.
• Influencer Marketing Integration: VaynerMedia effectively integrates influencer marketing into broader performance campaigns, leveraging authentic voices to extend reach and drive conversions. They understand how to connect brands with the right influencers to achieve specific marketing objectives.
• Data-Driven Creative Optimization: They use advanced analytics to understand what types of creative content perform best with specific audiences and continually refine their creative output based on these insights. This ensures that ad spend is always directed towards the most effective visual and textual assets.
• Always-On Community Engagement: Beyond traditional ad placements, VaynerMedia focuses on fostering active communities around brands, turning passive consumers into engaged advocates. This approach not only boosts brand loyalty but also provides valuable real-time feedback for performance optimization.

Why it matters: VaynerMedia's social-first, data-infused approach is particularly effective for brands in New York looking to connect with a digitally native audience and build strong, engaged communities. Their ability to blend creative content with performance analytics ensures campaigns are both impactful and measurable, delivering strong results in the modern digital landscape.

5. Accenture Song (formerly Accenture Interactive)

Accenture Song, previously known as Accenture Interactive, stands as a formidable force in the marketing and experience industry, combining creative agency capabilities with the deep technology and consulting expertise of Accenture. They focus on delivering hyper-relevant customer experiences that drive growth, using data, design, and digital engineering. Their performance marketing strategies are built on a foundation of understanding the entire customer journey, from awareness to conversion and loyalty, ensuring every touchpoint is optimized for maximum impact.

• End-to-End Customer Experience Transformation: Accenture Song provides comprehensive services that go beyond just marketing campaigns, focusing on transforming the entire customer experience across all digital and physical channels. This holistic view leads to more effective and integrated performance marketing.
• Advanced Analytics and AI-Powered Optimization: They leverage cutting-edge analytics, machine learning, and artificial intelligence to gain deep insights into consumer behavior and optimize campaign performance in real-time. This allows for highly personalized targeting and maximum ROI.
• Scalable Digital Platform Integration: Accenture Song excels at integrating complex digital platforms, including CRM, e-commerce, and marketing automation systems, to create a seamless operational environment. This enables more efficient data flow and better-coordinated performance marketing efforts.
• Innovation in Creative and Content Delivery: They combine creative storytelling with technological innovation to produce engaging content and advertising formats that capture attention and drive action. Their ability to blend creativity with data ensures campaigns are both compelling and highly effective.
• Strategic Consulting for Digital Growth: Beyond execution, Accenture Song offers high-level strategic consulting to help businesses define their digital growth ambitions and build the capabilities needed to achieve them. This ensures that performance marketing aligns with broader business objectives and fosters long-term success.

Why it matters: For large enterprises and ambitious brands in New York seeking a partner that can truly integrate performance marketing with broader business transformation, Accenture Song is an unparalleled choice. Their blend of creative, technological, and consulting expertise ensures that your marketing investments drive sustained growth and competitive advantage.

6. iProspect (Dentsu International)

iProspect, part of Dentsu International, is a global performance marketing agency that specializes in driving measurable business outcomes through a deep understanding of customer intent. They combine data, technology, and human insights to create highly effective strategies across search, social, programmatic, and e-commerce channels. Their mission is to connect brands with consumers at every stage of the purchase journey, ensuring that marketing spend delivers maximum impact and verifiable results.

• Intent-Based Performance Marketing: iProspect focuses on understanding consumer intent at different stages of the buying cycle to deliver highly relevant messages and offers. This approach ensures that marketing efforts are not just seen, but are acted upon by the right audience at the right time.
• Integrated Search and Social Strategies: They excel at developing cohesive strategies that combine the power of search engine marketing (SEM) and social media advertising. This integrated approach maximizes visibility, drives traffic, and optimizes conversions across key digital platforms.
• Data-Driven Programmatic Advertising: Utilizing advanced programmatic platforms, iProspect delivers highly targeted and efficient media buys across a vast network of publishers. Their data-centric approach ensures ads are served to the most receptive audiences, minimizing waste and maximizing campaign effectiveness.
• E-commerce Performance Optimization: For brands focused on online sales, iProspect provides specialized e-commerce strategies that drive traffic, improve conversion rates, and enhance customer lifetime value. This includes optimizing product feeds, marketplace advertising, and personalized shopping experiences.
• Comprehensive Analytics and Reporting: They offer robust analytics and transparent reporting to provide clients with clear insights into campaign performance and ROI. This commitment to measurable results ensures continuous optimization and accountability for marketing spend.

Why it matters: iProspect's intent-based approach and integrated strategies make them an ideal partner for businesses in New York looking to convert passive interest into active sales. Their focus on measurable outcomes ensures that every dollar spent on performance marketing contributes directly to your business goals, making them a reliable choice for achieving strong ROI.

7. PMG

PMG is a global independent full-stack digital agency that focuses on empowering brands to build more meaningful relationships with their customers. They pride themselves on a unique culture that combines technological innovation with deep client partnerships. PMG offers comprehensive performance marketing services, including media strategy, planning, and buying across all digital channels, driven by their proprietary technology platform, Alli. Their approach emphasizes transparency, collaboration, and continuous improvement to drive superior results.

• Proprietary Technology Platform (Alli): PMG utilizes its advanced technology platform, Alli, to centralize data, automate campaign management, and provide real-time insights across all marketing channels. This platform enhances efficiency and enables smarter decision-making for optimal performance.
• Integrated Media Strategy and Buying: They offer a unified approach to media planning and buying, ensuring that all digital channels, including search, social, display, and video, work in harmony to achieve overarching performance goals. This integrated strategy maximizes reach and impact.
• Audience-First Targeting: PMG employs sophisticated audience segmentation and targeting techniques to ensure that marketing messages reach the most relevant consumers. Their data-driven approach allows for highly personalized campaigns that resonate deeply and drive higher conversion rates.
• Full-Funnel Performance Optimization: They focus on optimizing performance across the entire marketing funnel, from brand awareness and consideration to conversion and customer retention. This holistic view ensures sustained growth and a positive return on investment for clients.
• Client-Centric Partnership Model: PMG prides itself on building strong, collaborative relationships with its clients, acting as an extension of their internal teams. This partnership approach fosters transparency, trust, and a shared commitment to achieving ambitious performance marketing objectives.

Why it matters: PMG's combination of cutting-edge proprietary technology and a client-centric partnership model offers a distinct advantage for brands in New York seeking a transparent and effective performance marketing solution. Their ability to deliver integrated strategies powered by advanced analytics ensures that your marketing spend is maximized for optimal results and long-term success.

8. Tinuiti

Tinuiti is a leading independent performance marketing agency specializing in search, social, Amazon, and marketplaces, and connected TV (CTV). They are known for their deep expertise across various digital platforms and their ability to drive aggressive growth for brands of all sizes. Tinuiti’s approach combines data-driven insights with innovative strategies to maximize ROI across the entire customer journey, helping clients navigate the complex world of digital advertising with confidence and achieve measurable results.

• Omnichannel Performance Marketing Expertise: Tinuiti offers comprehensive services across all major performance channels, including search engines (Google, Bing), social media platforms (Facebook, Instagram, TikTok), Amazon, and other e-commerce marketplaces, as well as Connected TV. This ensures a holistic and integrated strategy.
• Proprietary Data and Technology (Mobius): They leverage their own intelligence platform, Mobius, to consolidate data, gain cross-channel insights, and automate optimizations. This technology empowers faster, smarter decision-making, leading to more efficient ad spend and improved performance.
• Specialized Amazon and Marketplace Advertising: Tinuiti has particular strength in helping brands succeed on Amazon and other major e-commerce marketplaces. Their expertise includes optimizing product listings, managing ad campaigns, and developing strategies to dominate competitive retail environments.
• Creative Services for Performance: They offer integrated creative services that are specifically designed to perform in digital advertising environments. This includes developing compelling ad copy, engaging visuals, and video content that captures attention and drives conversions across various platforms.
• Advanced Analytics and Attribution Modeling: Tinuiti employs sophisticated analytics and attribution models to precisely measure the impact of each marketing touchpoint and allocate budget effectively. This data-first approach ensures transparency and maximizes the efficiency of performance campaigns.

Why it matters: For brands in New York looking for deep expertise across a wide range of performance marketing channels, especially those with a strong e-commerce focus, Tinuiti is an excellent choice. Their proprietary technology and specialized knowledge in areas like Amazon advertising can provide a significant competitive edge, driving substantial growth and ROI.

9. Merkle (Dentsu International)

Merkle, a leading data-driven, technology-enabled, global performance marketing agency, is part of Dentsu International. They specialize in the creation and delivery of unique, personalized customer experiences that drive loyalty and measurable business value. Merkle's strength lies in its ability to integrate deep consumer understanding with advanced analytics, technology, and media execution to optimize performance across all digital and direct channels, focusing on delivering a truly connected customer journey.

• Customer Relationship Management (CRM) & Loyalty: Merkle excels at building and optimizing CRM strategies that drive customer loyalty and lifetime value. Their performance marketing efforts are often integrated with broader CRM initiatives to foster deeper relationships and repeat business.
• Data Transformation and Analytics: They possess strong capabilities in data strategy, data integration, and advanced analytics, helping clients leverage their first-party data for hyper-targeted performance campaigns. This ensures messages are highly relevant and delivered to the right audience.
• Identity Resolution and Personalization: Merkle specializes in identity resolution, connecting customer data across various touchpoints to create a unified view of the consumer. This enables highly personalized marketing experiences that significantly improve engagement and conversion rates.
• Addressable Media and Programmatic Advertising: They are experts in addressable media, delivering highly targeted ads to specific individuals or households across digital, social, and even traditional channels. Their programmatic strategies are optimized for precision and efficiency.
• Performance Creative and Content Strategy: Merkle combines data-driven insights with creative excellence to develop compelling ad copy and visuals that resonate with target audiences and drive action. Their creative is optimized for performance, ensuring maximum impact for marketing spend.

Why it matters: For New York businesses focused on building strong, long-term customer relationships and leveraging their data for highly personalized marketing, Merkle offers unparalleled expertise. Their ability to integrate advanced data analytics with performance marketing ensures that your campaigns are not only effective in the short term but also contribute to lasting customer loyalty and sustained business growth.

10. Omnicom Media Group (Through its various agencies like OMD, PHD, Hearts & Science)

Omnicom Media Group (OMG) is the media services division of Omnicom Group Inc., a global advertising and marketing communications company. OMG oversees several highly regarded media agencies, including OMD, PHD, and Hearts & Science, each with its own specialized approach to performance marketing. These agencies collectively leverage vast global resources, proprietary data platforms, and cutting-edge research to deliver strategic, data-driven, and highly effective media solutions for a diverse portfolio of clients in New York and worldwide.

• Extensive Global Media Network: Through its agencies, OMG provides access to one of the largest global media networks, allowing for strategic planning and buying across all traditional and digital channels on an international scale. This ensures comprehensive reach and competitive media placements.
• Advanced Data Analytics and Insights: Each OMG agency utilizes sophisticated data analytics tools and proprietary research to gain deep insights into consumer behavior, market trends, and campaign performance. This data-driven approach underpins all strategic recommendations and optimizations.
• Specialized Agency Expertise: Within OMG, agencies like OMD focus on creative media solutions, PHD on planning and innovation, and Hearts & Science on data-driven marketing and real-time insights. Clients can benefit from specialized expertise tailored to their specific performance marketing needs.
• Proprietary Planning and Buying Tools: OMG invests in developing and utilizing advanced planning and buying technologies that enhance efficiency, optimize media spend, and provide granular control over campaign execution. These tools offer a competitive edge in a complex media landscape.
• Integrated Communications Planning: Beyond just media buying, OMG agencies excel at integrated communications planning, ensuring that performance marketing efforts are aligned with broader brand messaging and business objectives. This holistic approach maximizes overall marketing effectiveness and ROI.

Why it matters: Partnering with an Omnicom Media Group agency in New York provides access to a powerful combination of global scale, specialized expertise, and advanced technology. For brands seeking to navigate the intricacies of modern media and achieve exceptional performance across diverse channels, OMG's comprehensive capabilities offer a strategic advantage, driving strong, measurable results.

At Fueler, we believe your skills and work samples speak louder than any resume. Imagine showcasing your successful performance marketing campaigns, detailed analytics reports, and creative strategies in a dynamic portfolio that truly highlights your capabilities. Fueler is designed to help professionals like you connect with top companies based on tangible proof of your expertise, making it easier to land your dream role or attract your next big client by demonstrating exactly what you can do.

Final Thoughts

The performance marketing landscape in New York is continuously evolving, driven by new technologies, changing consumer behaviors, and an increasing demand for measurable results. Choosing the right agency in 2026 means partnering with a firm that not only understands the current trends but can also anticipate future shifts. The agencies listed above represent the pinnacle of expertise, innovation, and client success in the industry. By aligning with one of these leaders, your brand can unlock unprecedented growth, optimize its marketing spend, and solidify its position in a highly competitive market. Invest wisely in a partnership that will drive your success for years to come.

FAQs

What are the key trends in performance marketing for 2026?

Key trends include the increased adoption of AI and machine learning for predictive analytics and real-time optimization, a stronger focus on privacy-safe data strategies, the rise of connected TV (CTV) advertising, and the growing importance of authentic, influencer-driven content for driving conversions. Expect more personalized and immersive ad experiences.

How do I choose the best performance marketing agency for my business in New York?

Consider your specific business goals, budget, industry, and target audience. Look for agencies with proven experience in your sector, a clear data-driven approach, strong analytical capabilities, and a transparent reporting system. It's also crucial to assess their cultural fit and communication style to ensure a productive partnership.

What is the average cost of performance marketing services in NYC?

The cost can vary significantly based on the agency's size, reputation, the scope of services, and your marketing budget. Some agencies work on a retainer, others on a percentage of ad spend, or a hybrid model. It's essential to get detailed proposals and understand the pricing structure and expected ROI before committing.

Why is data analytics crucial for performance marketing success?

Data analytics is vital because it provides actionable insights into campaign performance, audience behavior, and market trends. It enables agencies to optimize targeting, refine creative assets, reallocate budgets effectively, and ultimately maximize return on investment by making informed, data-driven decisions.

How can performance marketing benefit a startup in New York?

Performance marketing is particularly beneficial for startups as it focuses on measurable results and efficient spend. It allows startups to quickly test strategies, scale successful campaigns, and acquire customers cost-effectively. It provides the agility needed to gain traction and grow rapidly in a competitive environment like New York.

What is Fueler Portfolio?

Fueler is a career portfolio platform that helps companies find the best talent for their organization based on their proof of work. You can create your portfolio on Fueler. Thousands of freelancers around the world use Fueler to create their professional-looking portfolios and become financially independent. Discover inspiration for your portfolio

Sign up for free on Fueler or get in touch to learn more.